Occasionally we chefs do like to eat out - and sometimes we just can't make up our mind what we want. On Long Island, the ready solution to that dilemna is a diner. When I'm roaming around the North Fork of Long Island, I love to stop by the Cutchogue Diner on Main Road. A very small eatery, sandwiched between more modern main street buildings, it bears a strong resemblance to a railroad dining car. It provides the classic diner experience - bygone-era surroundings, good food from a small menu, and a family-run feeling. Note that I mention a small menu. I have a problem with diners that offer multi-page menus featuring dozens upon dozens of selections. I know, I know, I just got finished telling you that when I don't know what I want, a diner is a great solution. However, rather than offering a hundred selections done fairly well, I much prefer a place offering a dozen items, well done.
So what's all this about small diners? No, I'm not opening one (at least not yet!). No, I wanted to explain why I'm boycotting larger diners. Last week after dropping my father off at JFK airport, my wife inquired if I was going to treat her to breakfast. She suggested a diner in Babylon where in the past we've enjoyed Belgian waffles and a unique brand of breakfast sausage. We sat down, ordered our orange juice and hot chocolate, then both decided on the Belgian waffle/sausage combination. The waitress was dismayed when we placed our order; the diner's waffle iron was broken. I'm sure you know the disappointment when you have your chops set for an item and can't have it. We re-grouped and settled for an omelet and French toast, with sausage.
Breakfast arrived with my second let-down of the morning. Gone were the slender, golden sausages I had often enjoyed here, replaced by short, fat sausages that taste like every other breakfast sausage out there. I've never been able to find those slender sausages anywhere else, and believe me, I've tried to find that breakfast sausage in just about every store on Long Island.
Fine, so I couldn't have what I wanted; stop being a spoiled brat, right?
Well, last night we picked up Dad from the airport. After enduring a five-hour cross country flight with no meal service, we thought we'd better get some food into him, toot suite. I bailed off the Southern State Parkway at Baldwin, and made my way down to Sunrise Highway. We quickly found a diner and pulled in. I'd already eaten dinner, so I thought I'd enjoy dessert or a thickshake while he had his dinner (or breakfast, as he chose a Spanish omelet). On the menu I spied a malted milk shake - I'm a sucker for anything "malted". The waitress' eyes grew large when I ordered, and she apologetically explained that they no longer had any malted milk powder, and that it really should be removed from the menu, as this happened at least once a night.
As Charlie Brown would say, "Auuuggghhhh!"
So I firmly believe the diner gods are against me; rather than tempt fate (and risk disappointment yet again) and with apologies to Guy Fieri, I have resolved to boycott diners. I'll stick with drive-ins and dives.